Prashnikaप्रश्निका
Code
About
‹ Back to the paper

Question 5(iii)(a)

10 marks

English LiteratureISC 2026 Improvement English Literature Paper 1Long answerBeethoven - Shane Koyczan

Answer the following in detail.

Trace the journey of Beethoven from “Not good enough” to “The man MUST be a genius”, by making…

Trace the journey of Beethoven from “Not good enough” to “The man MUST be a genius”, by making relevant references to the poem, Beethoven. Write your answer in 200 - 250 words.

Answer

Answer

Koyczan traces Beethoven's journey from a beaten child to a recognised genius. He begins with a cruel childhood: "his father made a habit out of hitting him", wanting a genius, and he lived in a house "where mercy had to be earned through each perfect note". Whatever he played, the father's verdict was the same: "not good enough so he played slowly not good enough so he played softly". This "anthem" followed him throughout his life. As his career grew, his hearing failed. He was "hard of hearing", his fingers cramped "into the gnarled roots of tree trunks", and a musician lost his "most precious tool". Yet he went on composing the symphonies that played in his mind. He even "amputated the legs of his piano so he could feel the vibrations through the floor". The audience, however, was overwhelmed; his music was like an addiction, and even kings and queens could not resist. The turning point comes when the orchestra mocks him by "holding their bows a quarter of an inch above the strings, not making a sound". The poet says "It was perfect", since "the deaf have an intimacy with silence". The musicians are left "trying to calculate the distance between madness and genius" and finally realise that "Distance must be an illusion. The man must be a genius." The poem ends: "To know the man, all we ever had to do was listen." Beethoven thus rises from his father's rejection to universal recognition, through suffering and perseverance.