‹ Back to the paper
Question 5(ii)
5 marks
English LiteratureISC 2025 Improvement English Literature Paper 1Short answerBeethoven - Shane Koyczan
Answer the following in a paragraph.
Referring to the poem, Beethoven, show how Beethoven’s physical challenges and traumatic childhood…
Referring to the poem, Beethoven, show how Beethoven’s physical challenges and traumatic childhood led to him becoming an outstanding musician. Answer in 100 - 150 words incorporating the following details.
• Beethoven’s father’s role
• The challenge of his deafness
Answer
Answer
The poem shows that Beethoven's suffering shaped his genius. His childhood was cruel: "his father made a habit out of hitting him", and wanted his son to be a genius. Mercy "had to be earned" through perfect playing, and the father's anthem of "not good enough" followed him all his life. This harsh training drove him to practise and to reach perfection.
His deafness was the greater challenge. He became "a musician without his most precious tool", yet he went on composing the symphonies "playing in his mind". He even "amputated the legs of his piano" so that he could feel the music through the floor. The poet says "the deaf have an intimacy with silence", and so Beethoven heard music inwardly. His pain was turned into music that moved listeners, and the poet ends: "To know the man, all we ever had to do was listen."