‹ Back to the paper
Question 89
10 marks
English LiteratureISC 2025 Practice English LiteratureLong answerBeethoven - Shane Koyczan
Answer the following in detail.
How does the poem Beethoven underscore the message that despite personal challenges, man can aspire…
How does the poem Beethoven underscore the message that despite personal challenges, man can aspire to great heights?
Write your answer in about 250 words.
Answer
Answer
The poem shows that Beethoven, in spite of pain and neglect, rose to greatness, so man too can aspire to great heights.
Challenges: his father "made a habit out of hitting him", and he lived in a house "where mercy had to be earned through each perfect note". Whatever he played, "it was not good enough". His "fingers cramped up into the gnarled roots of tree trunks", and he lost his hearing: "he couldn't hear the audiences clapping".
Heights: he did not stop. He "amputated the legs of his piano so he could feel the vibrations through the floor". His music let the audience feel "explosions of heavenly sensation" and made them say "He was an addiction". Its power reached "past the towers of Babylon", "turning solar systems into cymbals that crash together", until "it looked like the entire universe had begun to cry."
The musicians who first "tried to mock the man" could only wonder "the distance between madness and genius". Koyczan answers "Distance must be an illusion. The man must be a genius." Beethoven turns suffering into music, since his thoughts were "moving at the speed of sound". Thus the poem says that courage, effort and imagination can overcome personal limits, and ends "To know the man, all we ever had to do was listen."