Prashnikaप्रश्निका
Code
About
‹ Back to the paper

Question 4(ii)

5 marks

English LiteratureISC 2025 Improvement English Literature Paper 1Short answerThe Cookie Lady - Philip K. Dick

Answer the following in a paragraph.

Had Bubber and his mother not made some crucial mistakes in the short story, The Cookie Lady…

Had Bubber and his mother not made some crucial mistakes in the short story, The Cookie Lady, Bubber would have been unharmed. Discuss how their mistakes ultimately lead to Bubber’s disappearance. Incorporate the following details and write your answer in a short paragraph of 100 - 150 words. • Bubber’s repeated visits • His mother’s attitude

Answer

Answer

Bubber's first mistake is his greed. He visits Mrs Drew again and again for her cookies, and Mrs Drew drains his vitality each time, so he returns home "tired". His mother, May, never looks for the real cause. She puts it down to food, saying "He’d do anything for a plate of cookies", and she calls the old lady only "crazy". His father Ralf notices that "There’s something strange about that old lady", but the parents still allow "one more" visit instead of forbidding it at once. They also let a tired and weak boy go alone. On this last visit Mrs Drew draws the most from him, and he walks home exhausted in the wind. Later only "A bundle of weeds, weeds and rags" blows against the door, which shows that Bubber is gone. Had he stopped visiting, or had his mother acted on the warning signs, he would have been unharmed.