‹ Back to the paper
Question 85
10 marks
English LiteratureISC 2025 Practice English LiteratureLong answerThe Cookie Lady - Philip K. Dick
Answer the following in detail.
How does Philip P. Dick turn the story, The Cookie Lady, from a narrative of an innocent boy…
How does Philip P. Dick turn the story, The Cookie Lady, from a narrative of an innocent boy visiting a kindly old neighbor into a tale of terror?
Write your answer in about 250 words.
Answer
Answer
Philip K. Dick moves from a comforting scene to terror by slowly hinting at danger and then showing its cost.
Innocence: the story begins with a friendly boy, "Where you going, Bubber?", and the "wonderful warm smell" of "Cookies with nuts and raisins in them". Mrs Drew offers "cold milk" and asks about school. It looks like a kindly old neighbour.
Hints of horror: the house is "overgrown with weeds, old dry weeds that rustled and chattered in the wind", and Mrs Drew is "a little dried-up old lady, like the weeds". She watches Bubber "drinking in each frown of concentration". Her wish for him to read is selfish.
The change: as he reads, "The little old lady was beginning to change, her gray wrinkles and lines dimming away." She feels "a breath of warmth inside her cold body for the first time in years!" When he leaves, "All at once the warmth left her." Bubber returns "All worn out", and his father says "There’s something strange about that old lady."
Climax: on the last visit "the chair was right up next to the couch". When she touches him "The old lady could feel the youngness of him", and she becomes young: "And this time it had not gone away." Bubber is "fat and dull, a dead white" and walks home with "his heart laboring".
Ending: at the door there is "Something gray, something gray and dry", "weeds and rags", and Ralf says "Just the wind." The reader sees what the parents cannot, and the ordinary visit has become a tale of terror.