‹ Back to the paper
Question 5
20 marks
English LanguageISC 2025 Practice English LanguageWritingComposition
Write a composition on the following.
All school examinations should be open-book. Express your views either FOR or AGAINST the given…
All school examinations should be open-book. Express your views either FOR or AGAINST the given statement.
Word limit: 450
Answer
Answer
Should Examinations Be Open-Book?
I am strongly AGAINST the proposal that all school examinations should be open-book.
First, the purpose of an examination is to test what a student has learnt and remembered. If students are allowed to consult books during the test, they will not feel the need to study properly. Memory, which is essential for understanding and applying knowledge in later life, will be neglected. A doctor, an engineer or a pilot cannot open a book each time he faces an urgent situation; he must know the basics by heart.
Second, open-book examinations will make the students lazy and dependent. When answers can be copied from the book, hard work ceases to be rewarded. Those who have studied sincerely for months will have no advantage over those who merely know where to find the page. This is unfair and discourages dedicated students.
Third, time is a limited resource in an examination. A student who has not prepared well will waste most of the time turning pages in search of answers and will end up with incomplete papers. Such an exercise tests skill at searching, not understanding, and the stress it creates may even be greater than that of a normal examination.
Fourth, it is difficult to frame questions that will test thinking skills at every level of learning. For subjects such as mathematics, languages and the sciences, a firm foundation of facts, formulae and vocabulary is necessary. If the basics are weak, the student will not be able to understand advanced concepts, and the standard of education will fall.
It may be argued that open-book tests reduce exam anxiety and encourage application of knowledge. This is true to some extent, and such tests may be useful as occasional classroom exercises or in higher classes for projects and case studies. But as a general rule for all school examinations, they will do more harm than good.
In conclusion, education is not simply about knowing where to find information, which the internet already provides, but about having the knowledge, discipline and confidence to use it. Traditional closed-book examinations, along with project work and assignments, are the fairest and most reliable way of assessing a student's real ability. We must therefore retain them.