‹ Back to the paper
Question 1(c)
30 marks
English LanguageISC 2018 English Language Paper 1WritingComposition
Write a composition (450-500 words) on the following.
‘The end justifies the means.’ Argue for or against the statement.
Word limit: 500
Answer
Answer
Do the Ends Justify the Means?
I stand AGAINST the statement that the end justifies the means.
Those who support the statement argue that a good result can excuse the methods used to reach it. A doctor may deceive a frightened patient to make him take life-saving medicine, and a nation may fight a war to gain freedom. Such examples appear convincing, but they ignore a basic truth: the methods we choose shape the result we get.
First, wrong means usually corrupt the end itself. A student who cheats to win a scholarship gains marks but loses honesty and the knowledge the examination was meant to measure. A reward obtained by deceit is hollow and brings fear of discovery rather than pride.
Second, once we accept that any means may be used, there is no limit to what can be done. History shows how dictators have committed terrible crimes in the name of a 'great cause'. Millions suffered because rulers claimed that their goals were noble. When everyone defines his own end as good, justice and law disappear.
Third, India's own freedom struggle teaches us the value of right means. Mahatma Gandhi insisted on truth and non-violence even when violence might have seemed quicker. He believed that a freedom won through bloodshed would carry the seeds of future conflict. His moral stand gave the movement strength and won the respect of the world.
Fourth, the means affect innocent people. A factory owner who dumps waste into a river to cut costs may provide employment, but he poisons the water that thousands of villagers drink. The profit of a few is bought at the cost of many.
It may be said that in rare emergencies, such as saving a life, a small wrong is permissible. Yet even then the act must be weighed carefully and must cause the least harm. This is the exception, not the rule, and it does not turn the principle itself into a virtue.
To sum up, the end and the means are like the seed and the tree: the tree can be no better than the seed. A noble goal deserves to be reached by noble paths. If we sacrifice honesty, fairness and compassion on the way, we may arrive at our destination only to find that it is no longer worth reaching.