‹ Back to the paper
Question 1(v)
20 marks
English LanguageISC 2024 English Language Paper 1WritingComposition
Write a composition (400-450 words) on the following.
A person should be judged by the way they treat their subordinates. Present your reflections on…
A person should be judged by the way they treat their subordinates. Present your reflections on this statement.
Word limit: 450
Answer
Answer
The Measure of a Person: Treatment of Subordinates
It is easy to be polite to those who can promote us, praise us or help us. Real character, however, is revealed in how we behave towards those who can do nothing for us. I strongly believe that a person should be judged by the way they treat their subordinates.
People in power often show their true nature when dealing with those beneath them. A manager who speaks respectfully to the peon, a teacher who listens patiently to the weakest student, and a homeowner who treats the domestic help with dignity reveal humility and fairness. On the other hand, someone who is courteous to superiors but rude and arrogant to juniors is merely a flatterer. Abraham Lincoln is said to have remarked that nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power.
Good treatment of subordinates also shows leadership. Great leaders like Ratan Tata are remembered for standing by their employees in crises. Employees who are respected work with loyalty and enthusiasm, whereas those who are bullied become fearful and resentful. A kind leader thus builds a stronger and happier team.
Furthermore, this behaviour reflects values learnt in childhood. A person who is considerate towards waiters, drivers and cleaners has understood that every human being deserves respect, regardless of position or wealth.
However, it would be unfair to judge a person by this single standard. Sometimes a superior may be strict because discipline demands it, and a subordinate may be at fault. Firmness is not the same as cruelty. A person may also be generous to juniors yet fail in other duties. So, treatment of subordinates should be an important measure, but not the only one.
In conclusion, how we treat those who have less power than us is a mirror of our true selves. Kindness shown to those who cannot repay it is the purest kind of kindness. If society judged people by this yardstick, there would be far less arrogance and far more dignity in the world.