Prashnikaप्रश्निका
Code
About
‹ Back to the paper

Question 3(iii)(a)

10 marks

English LiteratureISC 2025 English Literature Paper 1Long answerMacbeth - William Shakespeare

Answer the following in detail.

Do you think that Malcolm has the kingly qualities that Macbeth lacks? Justify your answer in 200 -…

Do you think that Malcolm has the kingly qualities that Macbeth lacks? Justify your answer in 200 - 250 words by referring to the Acts studied.

Answer

Answer

Yes, Malcolm shows the qualities Macbeth lacks, though he is tested before he proves them. Malcolm is cautious and wise. When Macduff comes to England, Malcolm cannot be sure he is not Macbeth’s agent, for the tyrant "was once thought honest". Rather than trust blindly, he tests Macduff by slandering himself as lustful and greedy, claiming he has no taste for virtues such as "justice, verity, temp’rance, stableness". Macduff’s cry, "O nation miserable", and his refusal to serve such a king prove his honesty, and Malcolm admits that "modest wisdom" has saved him from "over-credulous haste". Macbeth, by contrast, trusts no one and keeps a paid servant in every noble’s house (Act III Scene iv). Malcolm is also honest and humane. He withdraws his false confession and declares himself "Unknown to woman; never was forsworn". When Macduff hears of his family’s slaughter, Malcolm urges him to "Give sorrow words" and says "Be this the whetstone of your sword", turning grief into purpose, while Macbeth is called an "untitled tyrant bloody-scepter’d". Finally, Malcolm leads with legitimate support: England "Lent us good Siward and ten thousand men", and he can say "Our power is ready". His justice, truthfulness, humility and compassion make him fit to restore order to Scotland, where Macbeth’s cruelty destroyed it.