Prashnikaप्रश्निका
Code
About
‹ Back to the paper

Question 75

10 marks

English LiteratureISC 2025 Practice English LiteratureLong answerMacbeth - William Shakespeare

Answer the following in detail.

Show with reference to Act IV Scene (iii) of Macbeth, how Malcolm proves himself to be a steadfast…

Show with reference to Act IV Scene (iii) of Macbeth, how Malcolm proves himself to be a steadfast judge of human character. Write your answer in about 200-250 words.

Answer

Answer

Malcolm proves himself a steadfast judge of character by testing Macduff carefully before he trusts him. He is wary at the start. He reminds Macduff that Macbeth "Was once thought honest" and that "Angels are bright still, though the brightest fell", showing he knows that good appearances can hide treachery. He asks why Macduff left his family so suddenly: "Why in that rawness left you wife and child". He then tests him by slandering himself. He claims a lust that has "no bottom", a "staunchless avarice" and none of "the king-becoming graces". He wants to see whether Macduff serves Scotland or only power. Macduff at first excuses the vices, but when Malcolm says "I am as I have spoken", Macduff cries "No, not to live" and "O Scotland, Scotland!" This is the proof Malcolm needs. He judges Macduff rightly, calling his grief a "noble passion" and "Child of integrity". He admits "my first false speaking" was against himself and says "Unspeak mine own detraction". He explains that Macbeth "hath sought to win me" by such tricks, and that "modest wisdom plucks me" back from "over-credulous haste". He also proves practical: Old Siward is already setting out "with ten thousand warlike men". When the news of Macduff’s family comes, Malcolm says "Give sorrow words" and "Be this the whetstone of your sword." He is both shrewd and humane.