Prashnikaप्रश्निका
Code
About
‹ Back to the paper

Question 4(iii)(b)

10 marks

English LiteratureISC 2026 Improvement English Literature Paper 1Long answerAtithi/Guest - Rabindranath Tagore

Answer the following in detail.

Compare and contrast the character of Charushashi with that of Sonamani. Show how Sonamani and…

Compare and contrast the character of Charushashi with that of Sonamani. Show how Sonamani and Charushashi present two aspects of womanhood in the short story, Atithi. Answer in 200 - 250 words, by making relevant references to the story.

Answer

Answer

In Atithi, Tagore shows two different aspects of womanhood in Charushashi and Sonamani. Charu is the only child of doting parents, "sole claimant on their affection". She is wilful and obstinate: "There was no end to her wilfulness and obstinacy." She is openly jealous of Tarapada's talents, so that she is "full of envy and jealousy", and she shouts at his songs. She is possessive, for she resents Sonamani's closeness to Tarapada, and she stamps on his flute, crying "I want to smash it!" She insists on learning English with him, and she throws a fuss when books are banned. Her feelings are passionate, spoilt and expressed through temper. Sonamani, "widowed at the age of five", is Charu's playmate, but she is gentle, shy and restrained. She feels afraid of Charu where Tarapada is concerned, and with "her heart in her mouth" she waits outside his room. She speaks softly, and asks after her mother. Her affection for Tarapada is quiet and sincere, as he is her "Dada". The two girls contrast in status, temperament and freedom. Charu, protected and indulged, can be demanding and assertive, whereas Sonamani, shaped by early widowhood, is modest and self-effacing. Together they present the spirited, pampered girl and the restrained, sorrowful one, and both are drawn to the wandering guest who leaves them behind.